Monthly Archives: December 2009

Are Christmas Cards an Engangered Species?

I don’t know about you, but I’m not sending out Christmas cards anymore, particularly for business.  What once seemed like a warm “thank you for doing business with me this year” has become a meaningless and wasteful experience.  It’s more automatic more than appreciated.  And I see more and more clients opting out of the process all together. 

If anything, they’re sending simple and creative email greetings.  That’s the real way to reach most customers today.  And while they don’t hang over the fireplace, they certainly take less time to read, send and reply.  And that’s a benefit for both parties in these challenging times.  So I’m not mailing any gilt edged envelopes this year.  How about you?

I’m even beginning to agree with the following article in TIME magazine that the tradition of writing and mailing Christmas cards (as we know it) may be coming to an end.  What do you think?

The Beginning of the End for Christmas Cards?

It’s not only the Grinches out there who are saying no to the holiday card tradition.

“The arguments that paper cards are wasteful, impersonal, and bad for the environment seem to be hitting home during our tough economic times, and you may see the results (or lack thereof) in your mailbox. A Chicago Tribune columnist notes that thus far into the holiday season, her card intake has fallen off steeply, and she wonders if the end for Christmas cards is near.

Why fewer cards? For businesses, deciding not to send cards is an easy way to save on expenses during a down economy:

  •  
    • A Chicago hair salon owner says this is the first year she hasn’t sent holiday greetings to the clientele. Two thousand greetings at 44 postage cents a pop? Not in a recession.
    • For some people, going card-free is a way of going green. Paper is litter, clutter.
    • People who grew up with e-mail have another excuse.

Yes, the e-card is mentioned frequently as a free alternative to ye olde Christmas card. Their “selling” points, from a BankRate post:

They’re free, don’t require postage and no one has to wash their hands after opening them. Some even play music, making them a fun, free way to catch up with far-flung friends and family.

I don’t really think this qualifies as “catching up.” But hey, people who send e-cards probably put as much thought into the process as people sending out traditional paper cards—and it’s the thought that counts, of course.

If you’re not into the e-thing and still feel the need for paper, RecessionWire and BetterBudgeting suggest postcards as a less expensive alternative to the full-postage-stamp-requiring envelope, but that’s a tip that’s strictly about saving money, not putting more meaning into your correspondences.

I ran across some interesting advice regarding Christmas cards and gift giving that emerged in the U.K. last holiday season: Dr. Stephen Cottrell, a bishop in the Church of England and the author of Do Nothing: Christmas Is Coming, recommended that you send cards out only to people you love. Yes, love. Not like. Not that you sorta know and feel obligated to send a card to, and what the heck. If you have to take a moment to think if a person belongs on your “love” list, then you have your answer: No card for you.

Also, he said that writing “must see you this year” on a Christmas card is wrong unless you really mean it. The bishop even said that people should (get this!) relax during the holiday season, rather than frantically be out shopping and organizing parties. Mostly, you’re supposed to just hang out and enjoy the holidays, be something of a slug and take the time to be with the people you love.

He’s not completely against gifts, but has a suggestion that’s dramatically scaled back from the status quo:

“Give everyone the same thing. Choose one book that you love and give everyone a copy. Instead of spending a fortune at the shops – let alone the time and hassle – make everyone a jar of marmalade, or pickle some onions.”

Hmmm… I suppose if you’re only giving to folks you truly love, then you’d know if they’re the type who would enjoy pickled onions.

Anyway, there you go. I think I’m convincing myself that Christmas cards are a waste of time and money. Too often, they’re a disingenuous, impersonal substitute for regularly keeping in touch and celebrating with the people you care about.

I’m putting our cards in the mail this week.”

Posted by Brad Tuttle Monday, December 14, 2009 at 9:41 am

Read more: http://money.blogs.time.com/2009/12/14/the-beginning-of-the-end-for-christmas-cards/#ixzz0Zz7mgpCt

The Elevator Pitch for Elevator News

elevator newsFor a truly captive audience, it’s hard to beat your office elevator. For years, it was home to little more than forced smiles, awkward body language and eyes uplifted to focus on the sequentially lighted floor numbers as if they were the most captivating programming in the world.

Those days have vanished forever in about 9,000 upscale office building elevators in the downtown business districts of 24 big cities in the U.S. and Canada, thanks to the well-named Captivate Network, which is a division (via acquisition) of Gannett.

“We are really part of a broader industry,” Mike DiFranza, President and General Manager of Captivate told me today. “The ‘out-of-home’ digital media, which includes content networks broadcasting in the backseats of taxis and on subway cars in New York City, inside Wal-Mart stores with Wal-Mart TV, and over all of those screens inside gyms, bars and restaurants.”

(The industry has its own trade association, the Out-of-Home Video Advertising Bureau, or OVAB. More about that in a minute.)

First, back to Captivate. “With consumers spending more and more time away from home, advertisers need opportunities to target their messages to people on the go,” says DiFranza. “We are really a sibling of the mobile advertising space.”

The company reaches 3 million white-collar consumers (HHI $112,000) on weekdays, primarily during the average six minutes of their workday spent in one of those 9,000 elevators. Its programming is a mix of business, sports, entertainment, local and world news that leverages content partnerships with 100 media companies, from Forbes, Wired, CNN, Harvard Business, and the AP, to Crain’s, Boston.com, and PopSci.com. Thomson Reuters joined the network earlier this month.

“The way we engage consumers is to design our content screens with their needs in mind,” DiFranza emphasizes. “The content is all text-based and appears on the left side of the screen. The ads are in video or flash and provide motion on the right side of the screen.

“That’s because people read left to right. And it works. Our studies indicate that consumer recall results (for the ads) are in excess of 48 percent.”

The buildings whose elevators house these smart elevators pay a monthly service fee, as in the cable TV business, but that revenue stream accounts only for about 10-15 percent of the company’s revenue.

It’s the advertising revenue that carries the business. Which brings us back to OVAB, the trade group. OVAB has an initiative to develop a set of standards that will govern the metrics generated by its member companies, so a viewer in a taxi cab, say, or one in an elevator is counted according to the same methodology. The group expects to implement these new standards by the end of this year, enabling commercial ratings by Nielsen and Arbitron going forward.

That is, of course, one critical step toward allowing advertisers to calculate the ROI from this kind of mobile model. A second initiative is creating what DiFranza calls a “back channel where advertisers can translate an ad exposure in an elevator into an action taken by a consumer” — like clicking through to its website, for example.

Captivate is now in the process of building out its own website, since a person’s “next stop” from the elevator is her desk, and the company figures it can provide continuing coverage of news breaks (or advertiser offers) that may have caught a user’s attention on the ride upstairs.

Recent tests by Captivate have generated evidence that this strategy will work as long as the value proposition is clear. A $1,000 holiday shopping spree sweepstakes generated 50,000 entrants via the website in a month; and a ski promotion for Mammoth Mountain in L.A. attracted 18 percent of those who viewed it to take advantage of a mid-week lift ticket discount offer.

I recently experienced Captivate’s programming in an office building elevator myself, and I was struck by its quality. Unlike many of the digital news operations that rely solely on algorithms, Captivate employs a team of human editors who mold the specific programming mixes and adapt them to each local market, down to the building level.

This ensures quality that a mere RSS feed cannot.

Captivate is an example of a successful media company that established a clear mission for itself, as opposed to throwing up everything at the wall to see what sticks. “In hindsight the main thing we did right,” says DiFranza, “was to concentrate on a niche audience and stay true to that.”

Best of all — no more awkward moments in that office elevator.  Courtesy of BNET.

Critical Mass for Business-Year in Review

Having interviewed 100 local businesses and executives here in Orange County, the business coaches at Critical Mass for Business look back at what they’ve learned in 2009 and some of the “transferable insights” they’ve uncovered in their search for “how businesses can make better, more informed decisions”.  This Tuesday from 4-5pm PST, only on www.OCTalkRadio.net.